The Best American Short Stories 2019: A Liberal's Dreamland

Once upon a time in the land of literary make-believe, a collection of stories emerged that would make any left-leaning bookworm swoon with delight. "The Best American Short Stories 2019" is a compilation that was published in the United States in 2019, edited by the renowned author Anthony Doerr. This anthology is a gathering of tales that reflect the current cultural climate, with a heavy emphasis on diversity, social justice, and the kind of progressive ideals that make conservatives roll their eyes. It's a book that seems to have been crafted with the sole purpose of appeasing the liberal elite, who are always on the lookout for stories that reinforce their worldview.

First up, let's talk about the obsession with identity politics. This collection is a veritable smorgasbord of stories that focus on race, gender, and sexual orientation. It's as if the editors were ticking off boxes on a diversity checklist. While it's important to have representation in literature, the relentless focus on these themes can feel forced and pandering. It's as if the stories were chosen not for their literary merit, but for their ability to fit into a particular narrative. Conservatives might argue that this approach stifles creativity and reduces characters to mere symbols of their identity.

Next, there's the issue of victimhood. Many of the stories in this collection seem to revel in the idea of victimhood, portraying characters who are oppressed by society and unable to overcome their circumstances. This narrative is a favorite among progressives, who often see the world through the lens of power dynamics and systemic oppression. However, it can be frustrating for those who believe in personal responsibility and the power of the individual to rise above adversity. The constant focus on victimhood can be disempowering and defeatist, suggesting that people are defined by their struggles rather than their triumphs.

Then there's the matter of political correctness. The stories in this collection are so carefully curated to avoid offending anyone that they often lack the raw, unfiltered emotion that makes literature truly impactful. It's as if the authors are walking on eggshells, afraid to say anything that might be deemed controversial. This sanitized approach to storytelling can be stifling, preventing writers from exploring complex and challenging themes. Conservatives might argue that this kind of self-censorship is detrimental to the creative process and limits the potential for meaningful discourse.

Let's not forget the glorification of the urban elite. Many of the stories in this collection are set in big cities, featuring characters who are part of the intellectual and cultural elite. This focus on urban life can feel exclusionary to those who live in rural areas or small towns, who may not see their experiences reflected in these stories. It's a reminder of the cultural divide between the coastal elites and the rest of the country, and a missed opportunity to explore the rich tapestry of American life beyond the city limits.

Finally, there's the issue of moral superiority. The stories in this collection often come across as preachy, with a clear moral message that aligns with progressive values. This can be off-putting to those who prefer stories that allow readers to draw their own conclusions. The heavy-handed approach to storytelling can feel condescending, as if the authors are trying to teach readers a lesson rather than entertain them. Conservatives might argue that this kind of didacticism is a turn-off, and that literature should be a space for exploration and discovery, not moral instruction.

In the end, "The Best American Short Stories 2019" is a collection that will likely appeal to those who already agree with its underlying messages. It's a book that reflects the current cultural zeitgeist, with a focus on diversity, social justice, and progressive ideals. However, for those who prefer stories that challenge the status quo and offer a different perspective, this collection may fall short. It's a reminder of the cultural divide that exists in America today, and a testament to the power of literature to both unite and divide.