The Dichotomy of Despair and Resolution in 'Finished'

The Dichotomy of Despair and Resolution in 'Finished'

H. Rider Haggard's 'Finished' sweeps readers into an adventure set against the backdrop of colonial Africa, blending action with a poignant reflection on power and morality. This short story navigates the enduring human quest for meaning and justice.

KC Fairlight

KC Fairlight

When a story begins by thrusting you into its finality, it’s like meeting someone mid-conversation: intriguing and a little disconcerting. 'Finished' is a short story written by H. Rider Haggard, crafted in the late 19th century—a time brimming with colonial exploration and shifting social dynamics. Set within the resplendent yet turbulent landscapes of Africa, the story revolves around themes of power, morality, and the human condition. At its heart, the narrative pits Sir Henry Curtis and Captain Good against their nemesis, Umslopogaas, a warrior of great strength, in a clash that embodies both literal and metaphorical confrontations. It's a tale that captivates with its exploration of the timeless struggle between barbarism and civilization.

Haggard's storytelling intertwines adventure with introspective musings that were, and still are, unabashedly political. His writing didn’t shy away from reflecting on the British Empire’s imperialism while also engaging with the complexities of native cultures. Like any art that emerges from contentious times, Haggard’s narratives have been both celebrated for their storytelling prowess and critiqued for their colonial undertones. This duality offers a compelling reflection on literature’s power to both reflect and challenge societal norms.

For those of us trying to understand where Haggard stands on the colonial issues of his time, 'Finished' provides some answers while raising deeper questions. The story navigates the dynamic between the colonizers and the colonized, illustrating the balance—or imbalance—of power that defined the era. Sir Henry and Good represent the typical British adventurers, while Umslopogaas is depicted as the noble yet complex 'other.' Haggard doesn’t demonize the native characters but instead gives them depth and agency. This portrayal serves as a reminder of the diverse narratives often drowned out by dominant historical discourses.

One could argue that Haggard extends sympathy towards the colonized, sowing seeds of criticism against the imperialist ventures of the British Empire. Yet this is not done without simplifying certain ethnic and moral nuances—something not uncommon for the period’s literature. Haggard's writing encapsulates the deeply embedded narratives of his era, sometimes reinforcing stereotypes while also challenging them. Such works offer a lens into the cultural and sociopolitical frameworks that defined historical narratives.

Critics have long argued about whether Haggard was an imperialist sympathizer or a critic subtly voicing his dissent through fiction. Some view his portrayal of African settings and characters as a testament to his appreciation for a culture typically marginalized by Western writers. Others see these narratives as propaganda upholding Victorian ideals. This dichotomy speaks to the complexities of interpreting literature through modern lenses and illustrates that our perspectives are often shaped by our context just as much as the stories we read.

For today’s readers, particularly Gen Z who may be engaging with such historical texts through a modern, critical lens, 'Finished' serves as both a story and an artifact. It opens dialogue about how history and fiction can merge, reflecting the beliefs and biases of their creators. The story encourages readers to acknowledge the past while using its lessons—confronting its painful parts, understanding its beauty, and applying those insights to today’s world issues.

Reading 'Finished' is not merely an exploration of plot but an intellectual exercise that urges readers to question. Is Haggard critiquing the very society from which he hails? As Sir Henry and Umslopogaas face existential trials, the story transcends its immediate plot, highlighting universal themes of struggle, redemption, and the quest for a just future.

While the story neatly tidies its narrative in what might be seen as a complete conclusion, the layered subtext offers no simple answers. Haggard’s storytelling gifts us with vivid imagery of the African plains and its formidable warriors, yet we are left considering much more than adventure by the conclusion. The narrative prompts us to query our values, ponder on the human spirit, and reflect on how stories of the past echo into our present and futures.

The impact of 'Finished' lies in this very intersection of action and philosophy—a short tale packed with big questions. It’s a reminder of fiction’s power to transcend time and place, urging readers from any generation to consider how they too fit into the stories they create, tell, and inherit.