What Would Diogenes Say to Modern Political Elites?

What Would Diogenes Say to Modern Political Elites?

In an age-old marketplace showdown, Diogenes the Cynic confronted Alexander the Great about the true essence of power and freedom. This encounter reverberates today, decrying modern political theatrics.

Vince Vanguard

Vince Vanguard

Picture this: Ancient Greece, a sun-drenched marketplace in Corinth. Two historical titans casually walk into an impromptu philosophical battle. Diogenes, the famously irreverent Cynic philosopher, and Alexander the Great, the man who conquered the known world by the age of 30. The year? A hazy 336 BC. And what, pray tell, were they arguing about? The nature of power, freedom, and the ultimate folly of moral high ground. When Alexander approached Diogenes and introduced himself as the great king, the philosopher, nonplussed and relaxed in his barrel, simply asked Alexander to get out of his sunlight. Talk about brutal honesty.

This wasn't your average philosophic discussion. Forget about carefully curated dialogues between Socrates and Plato. This was raw, one of those defining moments that's still whispered about in classrooms and cafés. Diogenes was a man who wore audacity like a badge of honor. His belief in the virtue of living simply and honestly was loud, especially against a backdrop of opulence and pretense. As for Alexander, he was a strategist, a man of ambition who believed in the divine right to rule. Diogenes was unimpressed, and maybe that’s what made the interaction so memorable.

Fast forward to today—where power and simplicity rarely shake hands. The conversations around the virtues of minimalism might echo Diogenes' values, but our modern-day Alexanders are hardly listening. Just think about that scenario today: a plain-speaking, blunt philosopher encountering a suited-up political bigwig. Would honesty and simplicity survive in that coliseum of corruption and false promises? If you ask Diogenes, he'd probably scoff and say they never have.

For Diogenes, freedom was the ultimate measure of a man's character. And he wasn't talking about the kind of 'freedom' you find as a platitude on a campaign poster. His freedom wasn't bound by government interference or the shackles of societal expectations. You know, the kind of tight grip some leaders have on their citizens these days, ensuring nobody wiggles away from their well-drawn lines.

In a world where being correct—politically and socially—has become as necessary as having a smartphone, Diogenes would be a dinosaur. Speak clearly and stop sugar-coating, he'd say. Give a philosopher a stage today to demand a world governed by honesty and integrity, and they'd be shut down faster than you can blink. Too brash. Too insensitive. Too "anti-establishment." Oh, the horror!

Remember Diogenes' insistence on talking the talk and walking the walk? An odd concept in today’s political arena where empty promises loft around like balloons from a handsomely decorated podium. And they call it futuristic thinking to elect leaders who don't deliver on what they said they would because, you know, "things change."

Diogenes didn’t care about Alexander's conquests. Alexander could have worn a thousand crowns and it wouldn't have made a speck of difference to the philosopher. In fact, when Alexander offered him anything he desired, Diogenes simply replied, "Stop blocking my sunlight." That’s a far cry from modern life where most people would jump at even the slightest boon thrown their way by powerful figures. Diogenes' message seems almost radical when weighed against today's politics of appeasement and compromise.

Praise be, then, to men who do battle with words, courageously throwing them into the face of frenemies and phony leaders alike. Imagine the colossal struggle if a man aspired to do today what Diogenes did back in ancient Greece: shave off all that pomp and circumstances, and just think deeply and purely.

So, what’s left for someone like Diogenes in a world where even words can be weaponized and stripped of their truth? He'd probably laugh at the public spectacles we call debates and campaign promises. But here we are, with our modern-day Alexanders unbothered, believing themselves to be the ultimate masters of this universe. Small wonder then, that those with real simplicity and honesty prefer to look on from the sidelines.