Why 'Così' is the Opera You Didn't Know You Love to Debate

Why 'Così' is the Opera You Didn't Know You Love to Debate

In Mozart's 'Così fan tutte,' love's fidelity is tested with jest and provocation, challenging modern-day political correctness with timeless humor.

Vince Vanguard

Vince Vanguard

In a world where political correctness seems to be the ultimate virtue, it's refreshing to come across something that unapologetically bucks trends. Enter Mozart's "Così fan tutte," a story of love, fidelity, and human folly. Written by the legendary Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart in 1790 in Vienna, this classic opera unapologetically illustrates the fickleness and farcical nature of human relationships. Demanding your attention for about three hours, it presents a tale about two men who, urged by a wily philosopher, decide to test the fidelity of their fiancées by assuming disguises to woo each other's lovers. The opera illustrates a time when art was produced freely without the stifling grip of modern-day constraints.

Critics in Mozart's era might have found its premise a trifle scandalous, but in today's landscape, it's the kind of bold storytelling that dares to ask whether love is a principle written in stone or a feeling as ephemeral as a summer fling. The opera follows two officers, Ferrando and Guglielmo, confident in the unwavering love of their fiancées. As the stakes heighten, the women are put to the test, which brings humor into the question of love's constancy. The setting, an aristocratic Italy calmed by serene seaside views, provides the perfect background for impertinent games.

Amidst the pristine arias and orchestral mastery, the content is the stick prodding at the sensitive sides of those who champion progressive causes. A study of gender and identity finds little sympathy in a narrative where women’s fidelity is placed under a microscope. Is it a relic of a past mindset or a humorous jab at the universal human nature that transcends time? Dripping with satire, "Così fan tutte" serves not just as an entertainment piece, but as a cultural critique that ruffles feathers even centuries after its first performance.

One cannot resist pointing out that no opera would dare to tread these waters with such jest in a contemporary setting. The very title, "Thus Do They All," suggests a universality of behavior that would be instantly swatted down by those who believe in today's pat ideological shields. Is Mozart suggesting that monogamy is a charade, or that nothing in life is licit and perfect? Yes, and also no, as it engages not only the faculties of auditory appreciation but also of introspection.

Fans of "Così fan tutte" may argue that despite the shenanigans being a little politically incorrect by today’s standards, the opera gets to the heart of unpalatable truths which can't be taught in a modern ethics class. This begs the question: is it more offensive to expose flawed characters or to pretend that we live in a world devoid of any such flaws? Back in the day, the opera was simply an exaggerated commentary on human fashion. Today, it becomes a tool to question modern perceptions of gender and power.

Perhaps the greatest triumph of "Così" lies in its ability to strip away the lavish costumes and stage props, suggesting love’s simplicity and complexity all in one breath. Armed with timeless humor and engaging characters, the opera encourages us to laugh, love, and occasionally reflect on our hypocrisies. Could it be that art reflects life not to appease us but to make us uncomfortable?

Then, there's the strategic nature of its structure where the humor counterbalances any outrage. Most infidelity-themed stories breed angst, tension, bitter promises, and not a little heartache. In Mozart’s hands, it becomes a farce, a vehicle generously laced with comedic relief so that as the curtain falls, audiences leave charmed as much by the storytelling as by the ridiculousness of the human condition.

Despite its age, this opera still shocks and entertains as it speaks volumes about the intrinsic desires the age tries to suppress. The message? Be wary of trusting too much in the stability of feelings and human ethics. It's a nudge, a wink, a sly comment wrapped under layers of melody and orchestration. And perhaps, only Mozart could get away with such delightful subversion.

"Così fan tutte" challenges the complacency of audiences, plainly but wittily demonstrating that one’s true nature is often hidden behind social facades. This is precisely why it remains a beloved masterwork in the operatic repertoire, adored by those who revel in its candid take on human fallibility and mocked by those who fear its piercing conclusions.

Was Mozart ahead of his time, or have we merely circled back to the need for such perspicacity? While the story of "Così fan tutte" twirls humorously towards its end, it leaves behind impressions that are anything but shallow. In a world of increasing simplicity, it remains a rich testament to complexity.

So, if art is about mirroring life, then "Così" offers us a reflection that's part cautionary tale and part exquisite entertainment. It's a feast for the senses as well as the mind, reminding us that even in our pursuit of ideals, a good laugh at our own idiosyncrasies isn't just welcomed, but necessary.