Harlan Ellison's Watching: Unveiling the Lens of a Visionary Critic
Imagine attending a movie with a razor-sharp commentator seated next to you, someone whose insights are so astute that each film becomes a lesson in storytelling, culture, and creativity. That's kind of what it's like reading Harlan Ellison's Watching. This collection of film criticism and commentary by the iconic and often controversial Harlan Ellison was first published in 1989 but retains its sharp edge and biting wit even today. Ellison, renowned for his science fiction writing and fierce advocacy for creative integrity, brings an unyielding perspective into the world of film criticism. Why does this matter? Because through Ellison’s discerning eye, readers not only see movies differently—they see stories, humanity, and society from angles they might never have considered before.
Harlan Ellison was a prolific writer best known for his short stories like "I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream" and his work on The Twilight Zone and Star Trek. However, his essay collection Harlan Ellison's Watching offers a treasure trove of his take on film and storytelling. The compilation draws from his columns and essays he penned over the years, primarily for The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction. It is a reflection of the times, ranging from the 1970s to the late 1980s, capturing Ellison’s unfiltered views on what works and what doesn’t in cinema.
Ellison's writing style is both captivating and confrontational, often described as a 'deliciously articulate explosion.' His critiques are not casual observations but rather powerful assessments that challenge filmmakers and audiences alike to demand more from the cinematic experience. This book serves not just as a review of past films, but as a call to action for creators to strive for brilliance. Ellison’s enthusiasm about the craft of storytelling is palpable, and he breaks down every film with a blend of scientific precision and optimistic appreciation for storytelling potential.
What makes this collection stand out is how Ellison approaches each movie with a combination of fierce love for the medium and a relentless demand for quality. His reviews often go beyond the film itself, touching on broader subjects like societal norms, speculative futures, and human behavior. This is where his background as a science fiction writer truly shines. He often presents complex themes, yet explains them in a way that anyone, regardless of their familiarity with the film or genre, can understand and appreciate.
For instance, in his critique of lackluster films, Ellison doesn't just dismiss them; he elucidates why they lack the chemistry required to engage audiences. Likewise, when a film excites him, his excitement is infectious, reigniting interest in movies that others might have overlooked. Ellison had a unique way of turning film criticism into an art form itself, bringing a sense of optimism and possibility even to his harshest reviews. His hope for films to elevate human understanding and joy is evident throughout his critiques.
It's easy to imagine Ellison discussing films over dinner, his animated passion drawing you in whether you agree with his opinions or not. Harlan Ellison's Watching is a gateway to Ellison’s mind, offering insights not just into films but into the nature of creativity and the potential for humanity’s stories to evolve. Reading his essays is more than a passive activity—it’s an engagement with a bold voice that dares the world to imagine and innovate.
Ellison’s work in this book is also a fascinating snapshot of an era of films that many of us may only know through glimpses or reruns. It serves as both a history lesson and a critique on the effect these films had on contemporary and future storytelling. By highlighting both the strengths and flaws of the films of his time, Ellison underscores the importance of learning from the past to craft more meaningful stories in the future.
In conclusion, Harlan Ellison's Watching is essential reading for anyone interested in film, storytelling, or the power of criticism to provoke change. Whether you’re a casual film enthusiast or a cinema scholar, this collection will enhance your understanding and appreciation of the intricate tapestry that movies weave in our society. Ellison offers a masterclass in how to watch films deeply and meaningfully, making this book an invaluable asset to our ongoing quest to truly understand and enjoy the world of cinema.